A frustrating amount of the press coverage of the ascendant stardom of singer Stella Cole centers on the assumed incongruity between her generation (she’s 27) and her choice of material (the Great American Songbook). The stories painting Cole as some kind of missionary, bringing jazz to Gen Z feel like misdirection. Standards become standard only when they’ve endured, having been touched by multiple generations of artists. That anyone is surprised that there are Gen Zers making and listening to this kind of music is a banal observation, designed to avoid actually having to discuss the merits of the music. Cole is only 2 months younger than myself, so her age has never been a subject of fascination for me.
I have been following her career since I came across a video of her singing online - way back when she was billing herself as Stella Katherine Cole. In the short years since, she’s parlayed her viral success into tour dates across the globe and a record deal with Decca. She recently made her Broadway debut in Maybe Happy Ending. I’ve had the privilege of seeing Cole live twice, once at Birdland and once at Smoke, two jazz clubs in Manhattan. She’s a marvelous performer with off-kilter charisma and great taste. Not to mention her Garlandesque vocal talent. Her stylized, sort of old-fashioned phrasing and tone could be a cynical gimmick coming from someone else. But she speaks of her love for old MGM movie musicals with the passion of a true nerd. There’s nothing cynical about her.
Despite my status as a fan, I’m not sure I would have recommended her albums to the curious. She has a crowd-funded self-titled debut, a Christmas-y follow-up called Snow, both nice, if low-key affairs. Her first album after signing with Decca was 2025’s It’s Magic, which surrounded the singer with strings, glossing right over her quirky charms. A recent live album definitely comes closer to capturing her persona on stage, but I dislike modern live albums. They’re bloodless. None of those efforts truly recreated what it was like to be in the room when she sang. So, maybe Stella Cole was destined to become one of those artists, like Liza Minnelli, whose live performances were the true showcases of her gifts, not the recording booth. Nothing wrong with a career like that, but Cole’s most recent effort, Imagination, has arrived to ruin that narrative. Finally, here’s a great Stella Cole album.
The fundamental reason this album succeeds where It’s Magic didn’t quite get there is the support. Gone is the unnecessary string section, as backing Cole here are the three men who made up her band both times I’ve seen her at clubs. They are: Michael Kanan on piano, Mikey Migloire on bass, and Hank Allen-Barfield on drums. All three get ample moments to shine on Imagination, Cole sounds in her element surrounded by them, her voice as warm and flowing as it’s ever sounded on record. Her phrasing has taken on an elasticity in places, as she gently wraps herself around a lyric. So relaxed at times, the album can feel languorous. The danger in bringing back these old songs is that it is so easy for the whole project to veer into cornball territory. Mercifully, there is not one kernel of corn on Imagination.
And that could not have been an easy feat given which songs are taken out of mothballs here. “Polka Dots and Moonbeams,” really? What about “Singin’ in the Rain?” The latter song has been cited as a favorite by Cole, and the album cover invokes a scene from the movie with the same name. She hasn’t dug too far into the obscure reaches of the Songbook, instead opting to give new readings to songs we’ve all likely heard several different versions of. Including some by Cole herself.
When Imagination was announced, my curiosity was piqued when I noticed three songs on the track list were also recorded on It’s Magic: “Til There Was You,” “As Time Goes By,” and the title track of this album “Imagination.” When there are thousands of songs out there, why revisit these three so soon? I don’t know the reasons for that choice (in fact, I know nothing of the creation of these albums), but I’m fine with it after listening to the new versions. Perhaps the clearest illustration of how this album suits the singer better than the previous is by listening to both takes of “As Time Goes By.” Go ahead, go listen. I’ll wait.
See what I mean? Maybe it’s simply an issue of personal preference, but I like when the voice is the star attraction. It suggests intimacy and personality, two qualities on which traditional pop music thrives. If you can’t make it to a club to see this unique talent in her natural habitat, Imagination is the closest substitute.
Great insights! Stella Cole is a true talent
ReplyDelete